Marco Island Brewery - Marco Island, Florida

Silvia

We picked this place over Chinese and we will not be coming back.
First, we were greeted by unfriendly waiter who looked at us from bottom to top and was like whatever.
We ordered beers and they were good.
But the food was horrible 😞

I ordered a pasta but it was overcooked and over seasoned, it was not cooked by a professional.

My husband had a flat bread that tasted like a piece of dough with lots of sauce.

It came with a salad and blue cheese dressing 😫 the dressing did not taste anything like blue cheese and the salad looked like it was left overs salad.

I was hoping for something a little more professional, well done and was so disappointed.

And not to mention that the plates were melamine and silverware was cheap like from Dollar Tree.

🤨

Ronda K.

I had always known Marco Island Brewery to have very good pizza. So, last Friday night I ordered a pizza for pickup. Boy, was I disappointed!! I have never had a worse pizza. When I arrived home I noticed my hand being damp when I carried in the pizza. I opened the box to find the pizza literally sitting in a pool of grease. The grease had completely soaked through the heavy weight paper it was sitting on plus the box. It was grease on my hand. The pizza totally fell apart as I tried to remove it from the box because the crust was saturated with grease. The website says the restaurant is under new ownership. If this pizza is the new owner's idea of the great food we're used to from MI Brewery, they are sadly mistaken. Makes me wonder about everything else on the menu. This place used to be packed during Friday happy hour - sure wasn't when I picked up the pizza. I was surprised to see so many empty tables and seats at the bar, but now I know why. Here is a picture of the greasy pizza box. Won't be back!

Sam H.

We liked the restaurant, it has a nice vibe and feel. The food was good, our cheese pizza was okay but had good crust and flavor. The sweet potatoe fries were good. The kids meals are great. The kitchen crew is outstanding. They bring the food out. It was quick and hot! Our male server was 1 star at best. He sprayed cleaner in our faces while cleaning the dirty table we got seated at. (Ignorant move by this guy, usually I’d leave at this point but we were on vacation). Waters were overflowing making a mess. He was lazy compared to the other ladies and staff who were smiling and enjoying their jobs. Good spot on the island, but ask for one of the lovely ladies as a server.

Amber M.

The BEST food / grouper I’ve EVER had!! ( been here 2 nights in a row )i was really nervous going here but I’m glad I did. Me and my boyfriend both got the grouper basket with tator tots. And I could not stop going on about it. They give you a good amount and don’t charge u a lot like hell for some fish. Only down side was when u walk in it smells like porter potty. It smells bad in there. But the food was amazing! will definitely be going back.

Brian B.

This used to be one of my favorite spots but sadly has fallen apart in the last few years, the cleanliness of the place has gotten really bad, and it smells terrible as soon as you walk in. The staff is not friendly at all, the bartenders used to be great but now they are not very good, other than Shannon who is awesome. The food is still decent but the staff and cleanliness issues have taken the brewery off my list of places I go, very sad.

Michael G.

Super fast service. Place was clean. Food was real good. Had ribs. Cole slaw was amazing. Fries were amazing. Ribs were good.

Chad K.

Can’t say more positive things about this place. I had the chicken quesadillas with salsa. They were the best I’ve ever had! Service is great. There are enough TVs here that you don’t have to worry about missing a play from your favorite team.

Susan G.

Service was slow. Waitress was right by our table and could have acknowledged us to say she would be with us shortly, but walked away. She was slow to return to our table throughout the evening. Peel and eat shrimp were good; however, when brought out, we had to ask for plates twice.